
Lawrence Taylor has more time to devote to golf, now that he’s been axed from Dancing With the Stars. (picture courtesy of ABC-TV/Kelsey McNeal)
His footwork may have come in handy on the football field, but it did Lawrence Taylor no favors during his run on Dancing With the Stars.
The retired New York Giants linebacker and partner Edyta Sliwinska last night became the latest castoffs on the ABC dancing competition, leaving six couples remaining. For the first time in the seven-week competition, Taylor and Sliwinska posted the lowest judges score (21, which, incidentally, was their second-highest score of the season), and, in turn, did not rack up enough viewer support to last another week.
In finishing seventh, Taylor failed to approach the success of other NFL stars that put on their dancing shoes for the series, including last season’s runner-up Warren Sapp, season six runner-up Jason Taylor, season three winner Emmitt Smith and season two’s controversial runner-up Jerry Rice (whose fan support outweighed his fourth-place average score with the judges).
Over on FOX’s American Idol, disco (and Paula Abdul’s quirky comments) took center stage- but you would not know it judging by some of the performances. Week after week, Lil Round has become more of a lounge-singer-like act rather than a recording hopeful, losing any grip she had on viability. Last night, she belted a faithful rendition of Chaka Khan’s “I’m Every Woman,” but, yet again, she failed to leave any true mark of artistry (to use one of Kara DioGuardi’s favorite terms).
Kris Allen put his own spin on Donna Summer’s “She Works Hard For the Money,” stripping away the disco and strumming his guitar to an almost tropical-like arrangement. The judges loved it, and rightly so- it was the polar opposite of Rounds’ usual non-eventful fare. Paula Abdul made a rather bizarre analogy, though- she said that plenty of girls go shopping in the men’s department, but not many guys go shopping in the women’s department. But, she said, Allen did and found a perfect fit. The comments left Simon Cowell in need of a translator.
Danny Gokey produced another round of great vocal, but his performance of Earth Wind & Fire’s “September” lacked spark, further showing that Gokey is not exactly the competition’s greatest performer or showman. Cowell called it awkward and clumsy, and, as usual, he got it right. Still not aboard the Danny Gokey Love Train, but he arguably is one of this season’s best vocalists.
Randy Jackson may have found Allison Iraheta’s “Hot Stuff” arrangement a tad indulgent (she made it even more rock-infused than Donna Summer’s original), but he and the other judges could not get enough of the girl’s killer vocals. Favorite Adam Lambert again left the judges in awe- he took Yvonne Elliman’s (and The Bee Gees’) “If I Can’t Have You” and twisted it into a heartwrenching, tender ballad. Lambert, in true humble form, remembered to thank his arrangement collaborator. DioGuardi observed that Lambert had a Clark Kent-Meets-That-Guy-From-Saturday-Night-Live look- did she mean Saturday Night Fever? Likely so- but, the audience is becoming accustomed to her flubs, so carry on with the flubbin’, girl.
Last week’s saved contestant, Matt Giraud, chose the ironic “Stayin’ Alive” for his performance, and received mixed reviews. Abdul likened his Idolrun to her bowling- sometimes he throws gutter balls and sometimes he throws strikes, and she happily found this to be a strike. She added that unlike last week when the judges saved him, he saved himself this time, informing him that he’ll be back next week, as if it were set in stone. In fact, Abdul was full of bold predictions, telling Gokey and Lambert that she’ll be seeing them in the finals (she actually had done that very early on in the season, as well).
Rather inexplicably, three of the four judges praised Anoop Desai’s take on Donna Summer’s “Dim All the Lights.” Abdul complimented his choice of attire, saying that a real man knows how to wear pink”- okkkkkkkk, Paula. Thankfully, Mr. Cowell got a chance to speak this week and said Desai was mediocre at best and that it was his worst showing by a mile. Now, that may or may not be true (has he forgotten “My Prerogative,” and, especially, “Beat It”?) but can we send this dull boy packing already? Cowell “prayed that the tempo wouldn’t pick up,” but, alas, it did, and Desai veered into yet another unremarkable uptempo performance.
Tonight, two Idol hopefuls will leave the competition- and those two should be Rounds and Desai. I had been rooting for Rounds to put on an explosive showing, but she’s had opportunity after opportunity and has squandered whatever potential she had initially shown- turns out she really is little more than a strong karaoke singer (an assertion she vehemently disagreed with, but what else is she going to say?) To quote another Donna Summer track, enough is enough. Same goes for Desai- as unfathomable it it to imagine, the zzzzzzzz factor increased even more this week and it’s beyond time America dash his Idol hopes.
If, for some reason, Giraud ends up going in place of either Rounds or Desai, we can expect Abdul to proclaim that America got it wrong- and, she would not be alone in that thinking. So, let’s hope for the best… which in this case, means that the worst take their final bow tonight.