Christina Aguilera- seen here performing in Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates- is highlighting her last 10 years with Keeps Gettin’ Better- A Decade of Hits. (picture courtesy of Associated Press/Carl Abrams)
Just what is Christina Aguilera’s place in the pop pantheon? We get a chance to ponder that properly with her newly released compilation, Keeps Gettin’ Better- A Decade of Hits.
Following a stint as a Mouseketeer (along with Britney Spears), Aguilera’s first break came in the form of Disney’s Mulan soundtrack. “Reflection” was a top 20 hit on the Adult Contemporary charts, but didn’t cross over to the pop charts.
It was with her 1999 debut album that Aguilera became a teen-pop superstar, following the mold of Backstreet Boys, N Sync and Britney Spears. However, unlike that threesome, Aguilera didn’t have the Max Martin hitmaking production team behind her, and, rather, focus was more on the voice. Part Whitney Houston, part Mariah Carey, Aguilera soon developed a rep for having one of the industry’s most powerful voices.
That was in contrast to Spears, who didn’t display much of a voice and rather relied on her media status and other people for her continued success. Like Spears’ and her breakthrough/signature hit, “…Baby One More Time,” Aguilera had her own with “Genie in a Bottle.” The track was an intentional slice of sexual innuendo, and put Aguilera firmly on the pop map.
“Genie” became her first No. 1 on Billboard’s Hot 100, and Aguilera landed two additional No. 1 hits from her debut album: “What a Girl Wants” and “Come On Over Baby (All I Want Is You).” Before issuing her sophomore album in 2002, she released a holiday album, as well as a Spanish-language project. Also, she collaborated with Ricky Martin, as well as P!nk, Mya and Lil’ Kim on a cover of “Lady Marmalade,” the latter which became her fourth No. 1.
With her second studio release, Stripped, Aguilera got “Dirrty,” but the track- buoyed by a sexually charged video clip- initially tanked in the USA, failing to break the top 40; though over time,”Dirrty” became somewhat of a recurrent favorite. The second single, the Linda Perry-penned ”Beautiful,” fared much better, reaching No. 2 on the Hot 100 and becoming an anthem for self-love and strength.
Strippedconcluded its run with more than 4 million units sold, according to Nielsen SoundScan- roughly half of the debut’s sales, but impressive, nonetheless.
Aguilera’s third studio effort- a double album titled Back to Basics- mixed contemporary sounds with styles of latter years, such as the ’30s and ’40s. The effort sold less than half of its predecessor, but still yielded a top 10 in “Ain’t No Other Man,” and a couple other top 30 hits in “Hurt” and “Candyman.”
Which brings us to Keeps Gettin’ Better- the album collects 10 hits, plus two new tracks (including the recent top 10 title track), plus reworkings of “Genie in a Bottle” and “Beautiful.” The album- a Target exclusive release- provides a pleasant romp through Aguilera’s artistic discovery. She started out as one of the teen-pop crowd, but by adapting a quasi-Madonna approach of re-invention, has distanced herself from that pack.
However, what Aguilera needs to realize is that she doesn’t possess the artistic notoriety- or importance- of Madonna. Not that she needs be as great as her idol, though- she’s probably a stronger artist than a Britney Spears, but if she’s going to talk like she’s the next coming of Joni Mitchell, the material’s gotta be THAT great, and not just acceptable, pleasant pop, which is how most of her music could be categorized.
Based on the new recordings found on Keeps Gettin’ Better, Aguilera’s next studio album may take more of an electro turn. But, the four new tracks/reworkings on the album don’t contain any real magical moments; like the past hits, they’re fine- but certainly nothing to justify the pop-art Aguilera appears intent on making.